The “Better Bond:” How Life Insurance Redefines the Concept of a Safe Haven Asset

by BetterWealth

August 5, 2011 was an unprecedented day in American history. On that day, for the first time in America’s more than 225-year history, our credit rating was officially downgraded. Standard & Poor’s downgraded US Treasuries from AAA (the very highest rating) to AA+. Fitch ratings would follow suit over a decade later in 2023, downgrading the United States’ long-term credit rating to AA+.

This kind of thing might seem trivial … like some kind of symbolic defiance against America’s ever-growing national debt and Washington’s cavalier spending policies. In reality, even a tiny shift in America’s credit rating can have massive repercussions for the economy at large. After all, US treasuries are broadly considered to be the ultimate “safe haven” investment. Even when the rest of the world’s economy is spiraling, you can at least be guaranteed that Treasuries will hold their value. Investors assumed that if nothing else, the US government will print enough money to fulfill its promises.

Except that’s not how everyone saw the downgrades. Especially not my friend’s client Anthony…

Anthony was relatively young when he first became a client, just under 40 years old. He’d just sold off a lucrative family business — where he’d worked since he was just nine years old — making him a multi-millionaire soon after his father’s early passing.

Like so many immigrant families, they’d all been workaholics. Anthony’s father founded a small but successful manufacturing business — thanks in no small part to the endless help of his brothers, sisters, cousins and nephews. Over time their business grew, before eventually being bought out by a larger national competitor.

Unfortunately, Anthony’s father passed soon after the transaction was finalized. So he never really got to enjoy the fruits of his labor. And his last wish was that the family should take the time and enjoy that fortune they’d all earned together.

As a result, Anthony wasn’t preoccupied with total return like many other investors. He wasn’t obsessed over squeezing a few extra percent out of the family nest egg. As far as he was concerned, his family had already put in their work. Now it was simply a matter of managing their savings for the best possible outcome.

This kind of perspective is often lost on the modern retiree. The age of CNBC and the 401(k) has really pushed most folks into becoming “Main Street Investors.” And the mainstream financial media then does everything in its power to treat stock trading like it’s fantasy football, with many Americans eager to oblige.

Anthony, of course, was a smart guy. He’d seen plenty of stories of swindled investors. And in his mind, the added return of risk investments just wasn’t worth losing a single dollar of the money his father had worked so hard to earn over his lifetime.

So Anthony invested heavily in bonds and other US treasuries. Instead of chasing the higher return provided by equities, he stuck to fixed income investments — favoring safety.

Then 2008 came along, bringing an unprecedented debt crisis with it. Corporate default rates hit new highs. Anthony defaulted on a handful of higher-income bonds, prompting him to lean further towards safety and push most of his nest egg into treasuries.

Then his treasuries were downgraded in 2011.

As you can imagine, Anthony was more than a little upset.

After all, he’d sacrificed a great deal in terms of total return in favor of safety. Now it seemed like his “safe haven” investments were getting a little less safe each passing day.

This is how Anthony ultimately arrived at the idea of funding a substantial whole life policy in a trust that would benefit his whole family.

Unlike his bond portfolio, this new life insurance policy would provide guaranteed cash value growth that didn’t fluctuate based on market trends, interest rate changes or other external factors. Anthony specifically hated having to wait on pins and needles for each fed announcement, wondering whether a rate hike might swipe at the value of his portfolio.

There’s ultimately zero correlation between a whole life insurance policy and equities or interest rates, making it a true volatility buffer to protect a portion of the family’s hard-earned wealth, and in turn protect its future.

Most investors don’t have this kind of volatility buffer in their portfolio. So if they face an unexpected downturn during retirement, they’re stuck with the decision of either selling off assets at a discount, or potentially liquidating bonds to hold themselves over.

With access to a paid-up life insurance policy, you have the option of instead taking out a tax-free loan against your cash value, which allows your investments to keep growing and compounding uninterrupted.

Unlike the taxed interest paid on corporate bonds, the growth of their life insurance’s cash value wasn’t taxable. And they also had tax-free access to this cash value via loans and other qualified withdrawals. So if they ever needed to borrow against the policy for family trips or unexpected medical emergencies, the money was always there.

And of course, there’s not a single bond out there that comes with a liquid benefit for your heirs that automatically bypasses taxes and lengthy probate process.

So even though life insurance is not an investment, it’s still a powerful asset that can provide reliable growth, impressive liquidity, and unrivaled strategic leverage when it comes to managing the rest of your portfolio.

Life insurance can transform your prospects in ways that most people don’t expect ahead of time.

In essence, whole life insurance is the “better bond,” serving many of the same general purposes by ensuring guaranteed, reliable income and protecting your wealth from the unexpected.

Life insurance isn’t subject to credit downgrades. Most of America’s top life insurance companies are more than a century old, and your policy benefits are spelled out in specific detail years ahead of time. Your policy even grows tax-deferred, with all kinds of tax-free access and the ability to make paid-up additions to grow your cash value even further.

It’s true that bond portfolios will typically be more flexible, at least in the early years. But over time, the broader benefits, security, and peace of mind that come with whole life insurance simply can’t be matched.

Key Takeaways

  • Life insurance offers a guaranteed, reliable growth asset that is not subject to market volatility or credit rating downgrades, providing a true safe haven for wealth protection.
  • Whole life insurance policies serve as a powerful volatility buffer, allowing tax-deferred cash value growth with tax-free access via loans, which helps preserve and continue compounding family wealth seamlessly.
  • Unlike bonds and treasuries, life insurance policies bypass lengthy probate and avoid taxation on payouts, making them an unmatched tool for wealth continuity and estate planning.
  • High-net-worth investors and families benefit from integrating whole life insurance into their portfolios to manage risk, protect legacy, and maintain liquidity for unexpected needs or opportunities.
  • Life insurance is not a traditional investment but acts as a strategic asset providing impressive liquidity, tax efficiency, and peace of mind over time beyond typical bond portfolios.

Ready to see how this could apply to your wealth plan? Click the big yellow Clarity Call button and let’s map it out together.