Harriet was the sweetest old lady you could ever meet. She was a retired tax accountant with a quiet little home to herself in East Tennessee. Her husband had passed many years before, and her two kids had long since left the nest, but she was still an active member of her community.
Harriet sang in the church choir, she volunteered at the church daycare, and she always had a few folded dollars for the collection plate when that went around. So you can understand the surprise when, upon Harriet’s passing, he learned that this mild-mannered, sweet old woman had left a whole life insurance death benefit of over two-and-a-half million dollars to her beloved church.
Understandably, it was the gift of a lifetime. And it was coming from a woman who’d lived a life of modesty, never flaunting any apparent wealth. Harriet had even been perceived as a bit stingy. She was noticeably slow to update her wardrobe with new Sunday clothes, and she never missed the Wednesday night liver & onions special down at her favorite diner.
What none of these people realized about Harriet was that she had a massive whole life insurance policy that she’d kept funding throughout her life. Her policy’s cash value had become so large, in fact, that one of my colleagues who specializes in whole life insurance recommended that she could ease up on her paid-up additions (PUAs) if she wanted, potentially investing some of that money into the stock market instead.
Harriet’s answer is something that will stick with me forever. She told him that a company’s shares might go up, they might go down. A bond might pay out, and it might default. Why would she invest her hard-earned money in “might?” “Death & taxes are the only two certainties in life. Why wouldn’t I stick with something that’s built for both?”
Obviously, Harriet was right. She’d spent a lifetime working as a tax accountant, after all. Life insurance is not an investment. It’s not built to be a direct alternative to stocks and bonds, which is why those types of investments typically show higher long-term returns on paper. But we don’t live our lives out “on paper.” And life insurance provides a host of unique benefits that can become priceless when you need them most.
For example, just consider the core promise of life insurance … the death benefit. This is a pre-specified, liquid benefit that’s paid out to the beneficiaries of your policy following your passing. Unlike virtually every other asset you own, this benefit is exempt from the estate process and any other taxes, and it goes directly to your beneficiaries, bypassing the costly and time-consuming probate process. That means life insurance is a unique opportunity to give your heirs options…
While they might also inherit real estate, investments, or other property, those assets will have varying levels of liquidity. They may have to pay unexpected estate taxes, final expenses, or lingering debts. With the death benefit from a life insurance policy, you’re giving them the liquidity they need to cover these costs and continue to enjoy the same quality of life even in your absence.
Alternatively, you can hold your life insurance policy within a trust, setting terms and ensuring this truly once-in-a-lifetime benefit doesn’t go to waste. Take that a step further, and keep your whole life insurance policy inside a charitable remainder trust with a family office to manage it, then you’ve got what’s called the “Rockefeller Method” for building generational wealth (I strongly recommend that book if you haven’t read it yet). Or if your family’s wealth outgrows the need for a specific death benefit, you can do what Harriet did and make a massive, world-changing donation to the charity or non-profit of your choice.
And once again, not to be morbid … but as Harriet pointed out, death eventually comes to us all. No other asset is designed to deal with this inevitability quite like life insurance. That’s doubly true in the event of an untimely passing — something that none of us want to think about, but still happens far too often.
Meanwhile, in terms of tax benefits, whole life insurance becomes even more appealing. Because the cash value of your policy will continue to grow tax-deferred for as long as you’re alive. That’s part of the reason why Harriet made so many paid-up additions (which I recommend), because she knew she was feeding into a growing cycle of tax-free compounding.
Another interesting factor of whole life insurance is that you essentially have tax-free access to the cash value of your policy (or at least a large portion of it). Policy loans and withdrawals can be structured in such a way that they won’t trigger taxable events. So you could even spend down a great deal of your policy while you’re still alive, all without ever having to pay taxes.
In some cases, life insurance can also be a powerful tool for minimizing the impact of estate taxes, too. At present, the estate tax is only a factor for folks with a net worth of over $12 million, but that may change if tax regimes become progressive in the years to come.
And finally, there are the massive tax advantages life insurance has over traditional retirement accounts… Once again, 401(k)s and traditional IRAs tend to beat whole life insurance “on paper.” But they also come with required minimum distributions (RMDs) starting at age 73. Unlike life insurance policy loans, these withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income. And even though the balance of these retirement accounts will pass to your beneficiary upon death, they will still be subject to income taxes and a lengthy probate process.
Of course, I don’t entirely agree with Harriet. I still think it’s valuable to have stocks, bonds, businesses and a variety of assets that can ensure your wealth will grow for years to come. But when it comes to death & taxes … none of those assets can hold a candle to whole life insurance.
Ready to see how this could apply to your wealth plan? Click the big yellow Clarity Call button and let’s map it out together.