How to Get the Right Key Person Insurance Quote

Written by | Published on Dec 23, 2025
Topic:

BetterWealth is a education first wealth management firm, and provide world-class life insurance, tax, estate planning, and retirement services. Over the years they have become a hub of financial information and perspectives.

Every great sports team knows its success often hinges on a star player. But the smartest teams don't just rely on that star; they have a plan for what happens if they get injured. Your business is no different. You have star players—a founder with the vision, a top salesperson, a brilliant engineer—whose absence would be a major blow. Key person insurance is your business's contingency plan. It provides the funds to recruit a new star, reassure your team, and keep the game going. Getting a key person insurance quote is the first play in this defensive strategy, allowing you to see exactly what it takes to protect your most valuable players and ensure your business can weather any unexpected hit.

Key Takeaways

  • Protect Your Operations, Not Just a Person: Key person insurance provides tax-free cash to manage the financial disruption caused by losing any critical team member—from your top salesperson to your lead developer—allowing you to hire a replacement and stabilize the business.
  • Turn Your Policy Into a Financial Asset: Instead of a simple expense, structure your policy as an "And Asset." A permanent life policy offers a death benefit and builds accessible cash value you can use for business opportunities, making your money work harder for you.
  • Review Your Coverage to Match Your Growth: Avoid the "set it and forget it" mistake. Your business and your team's value evolve, so your policy must too. An annual review ensures your coverage is sufficient to protect your company's current success.

What Is Key Person Insurance?

Think of key person insurance as a financial safety net for your business. It’s a type of life or disability insurance that a company purchases on its most vital employees—the ones whose absence would create a significant financial disruption. If that key person unexpectedly passes away or becomes disabled, the policy pays a death benefit directly to the business, not to the employee’s family.

This isn't about replacing the person themselves, because some people are truly irreplaceable. Instead, it’s about replacing their economic value to the company. The funds give your business the breathing room it needs to manage the transition, stabilize operations, and plan its next steps without the immediate pressure of a financial crisis. For many businesses, especially those built around the unique talents of a few individuals, this coverage is a critical component of a sound financial strategy and succession plan. It ensures that the legacy you’ve built can endure, even when faced with the unexpected loss of a crucial team member.

How It Protects Your Business

When a key person is suddenly gone, the financial fallout can be immediate. Lenders may get nervous, investors might question the company's future, and daily operations can grind to a halt. Key person insurance provides a direct cash infusion to help the business weather this storm. The tax-free death benefit can be used to cover a wide range of urgent needs.

You could use the funds to recruit, hire, and train a talented replacement, which is often a costly and time-consuming process. The money can also be used to pay off company debts, buy out the deceased person's shares from their estate, or reassure lenders and investors that the business remains on solid ground. In a worst-case scenario, the funds can provide the capital needed to wind down the business in an orderly fashion, protecting the value for remaining partners and employees. It’s a strategic tool that provides options when you need them most.

Who Qualifies as a "Key Person"?

A "key person" isn't defined by their job title. It’s anyone whose knowledge, skills, or relationships are critically important to your company's financial success. To identify these individuals, ask yourself: "Whose absence would sink the ship, or at least cause it to take on serious water?" In many small businesses, the founder or owner is the most obvious key person, as they often wear multiple hats and drive the company's vision.

But it could also be your top salesperson who brings in 60% of the revenue, a brilliant engineer with proprietary knowledge, or a C-suite executive with indispensable industry connections. Think about anyone whose loss would directly impact your bottom line, disrupt operations, or damage your company's reputation. These are the people whose economic contributions are worth protecting with a key person insurance policy.

Clearing Up Common Misconceptions

One of the biggest mistakes business owners make is failing to identify all of their key people. It’s easy to insure the CEO, but what about the COO who keeps the entire operation running smoothly? Or the head of product whose innovations are your primary competitive advantage? Many businesses are dangerously dependent on a few individuals but have no plan in place to mitigate that risk.

Another common misconception is that this type of insurance is only for large corporations. In reality, smaller businesses are often far more vulnerable to the loss of a key employee because they have a smaller team and fewer resources to absorb the shock. Leaving this gap in your financial planning is a significant gamble. Properly implemented key person coverage isn't just an expense; it's a fundamental part of a robust business continuity plan that protects what you've worked so hard to build.

How to Get a Key Person Insurance Quote

Getting a quote for key person insurance is a straightforward process, but a little preparation goes a long way. When you have the right information ready, you can move efficiently and make a confident decision for your business. Think of it less like shopping and more like strategic planning. By taking a few preparatory steps, you ensure the quotes you receive are accurate and tailored to protect the future of your company. Let's walk through exactly what you need to do to get a meaningful quote that aligns with your business goals.

What to Do Before You Request Quotes

Before you even think about picking up the phone or filling out a form, you need to do some internal homework. First, identify who is truly indispensable to your business. This isn’t about who is most liked; it’s about whose absence would create a significant financial disruption. This could be a founder with the vision, a top salesperson who brings in the majority of revenue, or a lead developer with critical technical knowledge. Once you have your list, the next step is to estimate how much coverage you need. A good starting point is to calculate the potential cost of lost revenue, recruiting and training a replacement, and covering any outstanding business debts. This initial assessment will give you a solid foundation for your financial planning discussions.

The Information You'll Need on Hand

To get an accurate quote, you’ll need to provide a clear picture of both your business's financial health and the key person's details. It’s best to gather this information ahead of time so the process is smooth and efficient. For your business, be prepared to share financial documents that show its book value, market value, and any outstanding debts. For the key individual, you'll need their basic personal information, similar to what's required for any life insurance application. This includes their full name, date of birth, and general health history. Having these details organized and ready will speed up the quoting process and help your advisor find the most suitable options for you.

Working With an Insurance Professional

While you can request quotes directly from carriers, working with an independent insurance professional or a dedicated financial advisor offers a distinct advantage. An expert who understands the nuances of business planning can do more than just find you a low price; they can help you structure the policy correctly. They will shop your case with multiple carriers to find competitive offers that are specifically tailored to your company’s needs. More importantly, a professional can help you see how a key person policy fits into your broader estate and succession plans, ensuring it serves not just as a safety net but as a strategic financial tool for your business's long-term health.

What to Expect: The Quoting Timeline

Getting a final price isn't an instant process. The initial quote you receive is an estimate, and the final premium will depend on a formal underwriting review. The timeline typically involves an initial consultation, submitting an application, and then the underwriting period. During underwriting, the insurance carrier will assess the risk based on several factors. The key person’s age, gender, and current health status are primary considerations, and a medical exam may be required. Lifestyle habits, like smoking, also play a significant role. Once the review is complete, the carrier will present a final offer. This process can take several weeks, so it’s wise to start well before you feel you absolutely need the coverage in place.

What Factors Affect Your Quote?

When you get a key person insurance quote, the number you see isn't pulled out of thin air. It’s the result of a careful calculation by the insurance carrier, weighing various factors to determine the level of risk involved. Understanding these factors helps you see why your quote is what it is and what levers you might be able to pull. Think of it like a recipe—the final price depends on the specific ingredients that go into your policy. Let's break down the three main ingredients that carriers look at.

The Key Person's Age and Health

This is probably the most straightforward factor. The insurance company is essentially betting on the life of your key employee, so their personal details matter—a lot. A younger, healthier person generally qualifies for lower premiums because, statistically, they present less risk. The carrier will look at their age, gender, and overall health profile. This often involves a medical exam and questions about lifestyle habits, like whether they smoke. It’s a core part of the underwriting for any life insurance policy, and key person insurance is no different.

Your Desired Coverage and Policy Type

Next up is the policy itself. How much coverage do you need, and what kind of policy do you want? The size of the death benefit—the amount paid out if the key person passes away—directly impacts your premium. A $5 million policy will cost more than a $1 million policy. The type of policy you choose also plays a big role. For example, a term life policy (which covers a specific period) will have a different cost structure than a permanent life policy designed to last a lifetime. We'll get more into those differences later on.

Your Business's Financials and Industry

Finally, the insurance carrier will look at your business. They want to understand the context of the risk. The industry you operate in matters; a construction company might face different risks than a software firm. The carrier will also consider your company's financial stability. They need to see that the business can consistently pay the premiums and that the requested coverage amount makes sense relative to your revenue and the key person's contribution. A healthy business with a clear need for the policy is often viewed more favorably during the underwriting process.

What Types of Policies Should You Consider?

Choosing the right type of key person insurance isn't just about finding a policy; it's about selecting a strategic tool that aligns with your business's financial goals. The two main categories you'll encounter are term and permanent life insurance. Each serves a different purpose, and the best fit depends on what you want the policy to accomplish. Are you looking for straightforward, temporary coverage for a specific risk, or are you interested in a long-term asset that can provide your business with more than just a death benefit?

Think about the role your key person plays and how long you anticipate needing this financial protection. For some businesses, a simple term policy is all that’s needed. For others, a permanent policy offers valuable flexibility and can become a significant asset on the balance sheet. Many business owners also find it wise to add riders, like disability coverage, to create a more comprehensive safety net. Understanding these options is the first step toward building a resilient financial future for your company with the right life insurance strategy.

Term Life Insurance

Term life insurance is the most straightforward option. Think of it as coverage for a specific period, or "term"—typically 10, 20, or 30 years. If the insured key person passes away during that term, the business receives the death benefit. If the term ends and the person is still living, the coverage simply expires (though some policies offer renewal options). Because it’s temporary and doesn't build cash value, term life is generally the most affordable type of life insurance. It’s an excellent choice if you have a specific, time-sensitive need, like ensuring a business loan will be paid off or covering the time it would take to train a replacement over the next decade.

Permanent Life Insurance

Permanent life insurance, such as whole life, is designed to last for the key person’s entire life, as long as premiums are paid. While the premiums are higher than term insurance, a portion of that payment goes toward building cash value within the policy. This cash value grows over time and becomes an accessible asset for the business. You can take loans against this value to fund business opportunities, cover unexpected expenses, or even help finance a buyout agreement. This turns the policy from a simple expense into a multi-functional tool—an asset that provides both protection and a source of capital, which is a core principle of our And Asset philosophy.

Adding Disability Coverage

Statistically, a key employee is more likely to become disabled during their working years than to pass away unexpectedly. A key person life insurance policy won't help if your top salesperson has an accident and can't work for a year. That’s where key person disability insurance comes in. This coverage pays a benefit to the business if the insured individual becomes disabled and is unable to perform their job. These funds can help cover the cost of finding and training a replacement, offset lost revenue, and keep the business running smoothly during a difficult period. It’s a crucial piece of the puzzle for comprehensive business protection and falls under a broader insurance strategy.

Understanding the Tax Implications

Let's talk about taxes, because this is where many business owners have questions. For key person insurance, the rules are fairly clear. The premiums your business pays are generally not tax-deductible. You'll be paying for the policy with after-tax dollars. However, the major advantage comes when a claim is paid. The death benefit received by the business is typically 100% income-tax-free. For this to apply, the key employee must be notified and provide written consent to the policy, and the business must file the appropriate form with the IRS. This tax-free liquidity can be a lifeline for a company in a time of crisis, making a well-structured tax strategy essential.

How to Compare Quotes Effectively

Once you have a few key person insurance quotes in hand, the real work begins. It’s tempting to just scan for the lowest premium, but that can be a costly mistake. The cheapest policy isn’t always the right one for protecting your business. To make a smart decision, you need to look past the price tag and compare the underlying value, coverage details, and the strength of the company offering the policy. Let’s walk through how to analyze your quotes so you can choose with confidence.

Evaluate Key Features and Benefits

At its core, key person insurance is a financial tool designed to help your business survive the loss of a vital team member. As you review your quotes, think about how each policy would function in a real-world scenario. The policy’s death benefit should be enough to cover the costs of recruiting and training a replacement, paying off debts, or managing any other financial fallout. A good policy provides the liquidity your business needs to remain stable and reassure lenders, investors, and employees during a difficult transition. The best choice will directly address the specific financial risks your business would face without that key person.

Look for Policy Exclusions and Limits

The fine print matters—a lot. Every insurance contract has exclusions, which are specific situations where the policy won’t pay out. A common one is a suicide clause, which typically states that the policy won't pay a death benefit if the insured person dies by suicide within the first two years of the policy. Insurers also have a "contestability period," usually the first two years, where they can investigate a claim more closely to ensure all the information provided on the application was accurate. Be sure to read through these sections carefully and ask your advisor to clarify any language you don't understand. You want to be certain about what is and isn't covered before you sign.

Check the Provider's Reputation and Financial Health

An insurance policy is a long-term promise, and you need to be sure the company making that promise will be around to keep it. Don’t just look at the policy; look at the provider. You want to partner with an insurance carrier that has a long history of financial stability and a strong reputation for paying claims. You can check a company’s financial strength by looking up its ratings from independent agencies like A.M. Best. Working with a well-established, highly-rated carrier gives you peace of mind that the protection you’re paying for will actually be there when your business needs it most. This is a specialized type of coverage, so it’s wise to work with professionals who partner with top-tier insurance companies.

Where to Find Key Person Insurance Solutions

Once you know what you need, the next step is finding the right partner to help you put a policy in place. You generally have three paths you can take, each with its own set of pros and cons depending on your business goals. The key is to find a solution that not only protects your company from a potential loss but also aligns with your long-term financial strategy. It’s about more than just buying a policy; it’s about making a smart financial decision for the future of your business.

The BetterWealth Approach

We believe key person insurance shouldn't just be a line-item expense. Instead of a simple term policy that only pays out if the worst happens, we help business owners structure this coverage as a company-owned asset. Using a specially designed whole life insurance policy, you can protect your business while also building a cash value you can access for opportunities, emergencies, or to fund retirement plans. This turns your policy into an "And Asset"—it provides protection and a growing pool of capital. This approach aligns your risk management with your wealth-building strategy, making your money do more for you. You can learn more about our unique life insurance strategies and how they can benefit your business.

Traditional Insurance Carriers

You can always go directly to one of the large, well-known insurance carriers. These companies are household names for a reason—they are stable and offer a wide range of products. This is often the most straightforward route. You work with one of their agents to secure a term or permanent life policy on your key employee. The primary goal is simple protection: if the key person passes away, the business receives the death benefit to cover costs, hire a replacement, or pay off debt. While this approach is effective for pure risk management, it often overlooks the opportunity to integrate the policy into a broader, more efficient financial plan for your business.

Specialized Business Insurance Providers

Some firms focus exclusively on the insurance needs of businesses. These specialized providers often have a deep understanding of the unique challenges companies face. They might offer a more hands-on, "concierge" level of service, guiding you through every step from application to medical exams. These providers are excellent at identifying specific risks and may offer tailored products, like key person disability insurance, which provides benefits if a key employee becomes disabled and can no longer work. This can be a great option if you're looking for a high-touch experience and a provider who speaks the language of business risk.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Getting Quotes

Getting a key person insurance quote seems simple, but a few common missteps can leave your business exposed. It’s not just about finding the lowest price; it’s about securing the right protection. Think of it as building a financial safety net for your company. A small mistake in the planning stage can create a huge hole in that net right when you need it most. Let’s walk through the most frequent errors business owners make so you can sidestep them entirely.

Underestimating Your Coverage Needs

One of the biggest mistakes is simply not buying enough coverage. It’s easy to think of a key person’s salary and use that as a benchmark, but their value to the company is so much more. You need to account for the cost of recruiting and training a replacement, potential lost revenue during the transition, and the impact on client relationships and team morale. A good rule of thumb is to seek coverage that is five to ten times the key person’s salary. A better approach is to calculate the real financial impact their absence would have on your profits. Getting this number right is the foundation of a solid life insurance strategy for your business.

Focusing Only on the Premium

Everyone wants a good deal, but the cheapest policy is rarely the best one. Focusing only on the monthly premium can lead you to a policy with restrictive terms, major exclusions, or no flexibility for the future. Some low-cost policies might not allow you to convert them to permanent coverage later on, or they may come from an insurer with a shaky financial rating. Instead of just looking at the price tag, evaluate the overall value. Does the policy meet your specific needs? Is the insurance carrier financially strong? A slightly higher premium for a high-quality policy from a reputable provider is a smart investment in your company’s stability.

Forgetting to Get Written Consent

This is a critical administrative step that’s surprisingly easy to miss. You must inform your key employee that you are taking out an insurance policy on them and get their written consent. This isn’t just a courtesy; it’s a legal and financial requirement. Without this documented permission, the death benefit paid to your company could be considered taxable income by the IRS. This simple piece of paperwork ensures the payout remains tax-free, protecting the full value of the benefit for your business. A good tax strategy always involves careful documentation, and this is no exception.

Failing to Identify Every Key Person

When you hear "key person," you probably think of the CEO or founder. While they are certainly key, they might not be the only ones. Who else in your organization is indispensable? It could be your star salesperson who manages your biggest accounts, the lead developer with irreplaceable technical knowledge, or the operations manager who ensures everything runs like clockwork. Failing to identify all the individuals whose absence would cause a significant financial disruption is a major oversight. Take a comprehensive look at your team and identify everyone who is truly vital to your success to ensure your insurance coverage has no gaps.

How Often Should You Review Your Policy?

Getting your key person policy in place is a huge step, but it’s not a one-and-done task. Think of it like any other critical asset in your business—it needs regular check-ins to make sure it’s still doing its job effectively. Your business is constantly evolving, and the value of your key people will change right along with it. A policy that was perfect two years ago might leave you underinsured today.

Staying on top of your policy isn't about being pessimistic; it's about being a smart, proactive leader. A regular review ensures that the protection you've put in place accurately reflects the reality of your business and the immense value your top talent brings. This simple habit can make all the difference, ensuring your company has the resources it needs to weather a storm and continue to thrive. It’s a core part of building a resilient business and practicing the kind of intentional living that protects your future.

When to Reassess Your Coverage Amount

The primary reason to review your policy is to ensure the coverage amount still makes sense. The financial impact of losing a key employee isn't static. As your business grows, so does their contribution. For example, has your head of sales doubled their book of business since you first took out the policy? Did your lead engineer develop a new technology that’s now central to your product? These achievements directly increase their value to the company. An annual review helps you adjust the coverage to match this new reality, ensuring the payout would be enough to cover the true cost of recruiting, hiring, and training a replacement without disrupting your operations.

Events That Should Trigger a Policy Review

While an annual check-in is a great baseline, certain business and life events should prompt an immediate policy review. Don't wait for your yearly calendar reminder if something significant changes. These triggers include major shifts like a new round of funding, a substantial increase in business revenue, or a key person receiving a major promotion or salary increase. You should also review the policy if you hire a new executive who qualifies as a key person. It’s wise to reassess all your life insurance policies after major financial changes, and key person insurance is no different. Staying agile with your coverage is crucial for optimal protection.

Best Practices for Your Annual Review

To make this process seamless, build it into your existing business calendar. A great time to conduct your review is alongside your annual financial planning or tax preparation. Set a recurring calendar reminder so it never falls through the cracks. During the review, you’ll want to confirm that the coverage amount is still adequate, the policy details are correct, and the business is still properly listed as the beneficiary. This is also a good opportunity to discuss the policy's performance with your financial professional. Having a consistent, simple process turns what could be a chore into a powerful strategic advantage for your business.

Related Articles

Frequently Asked Questions

How do we calculate how much coverage we actually need? While a common shortcut is to multiply the key person's salary by five or ten, a more strategic approach is to think about the total financial impact of their absence. Consider the potential loss in profits, the high cost of recruiting and training a top-tier replacement, and any outstanding loans that person's expertise helps secure. The right coverage amount should provide enough capital to manage this transition smoothly without putting the company's financial health at risk.

Is this type of insurance only for the founder or CEO? Not at all. A key person is defined by their financial value to the company, not their job title. It could be the head of sales who manages your most important client relationships, a brilliant engineer with unique technical knowledge, or the COO who keeps the entire operation running. If someone's sudden absence would cause a significant financial disruption, they are a key person worth protecting.

What happens to the policy if the key employee leaves the company? You have a few options, and the best choice depends on the type of policy you have. If it's a term policy, you can simply cancel it. If you have a permanent policy with cash value, the business can choose to surrender the policy and receive the accumulated cash value. In some cases, you might arrange to transfer the policy's ownership to the departing employee as part of their severance package.

Why would a business choose a more expensive permanent policy over a simple term policy? Think of it as the difference between renting and owning. A term policy is like renting protection—it's a pure expense that covers you for a specific period. A permanent policy is an asset your company owns. It provides the same death benefit protection while also building a cash value that appears on your balance sheet. This cash value becomes a source of liquid capital the business can borrow against for opportunities or emergencies, making your money do more than one job.

Can my business write off the premiums for this insurance? Generally, no. The premiums for key person insurance are not considered a tax-deductible business expense. However, the crucial trade-off is that when the policy pays out, the death benefit is typically received by the business completely income-tax-free. This provides a significant infusion of tax-free capital precisely when the company needs it most.